He was known as John 'Brown' Macneil because of his hair colour and to distinguish him from the three other John MacNeils from Barra who were in the same Regiment. In NS he married a Mary Grant. They had several children. I have plenty of details regarding his descendents but am keen to find - if possible - details of John 'Brown' MacNeil's parents and place of birth on Barra.
The story goes that when he enlisted in 1778 it was to take the place of a brother who had been conscripted and was subsequently 'released' when John enlisted.
I understand that in Scotland no BMD records prior to 1805 exist, but am hoping against hope to come across someone from Barra or with knowledge of Barra history who might be able to help. I'm an incorrigible romantic who still believes that somewhere there might be an old shoebox full of pre-1805 documents/letters about Barra MacNeils.

Any assistance much appreciated. Thanks!
Donna