Everything matches, none of the other hits fit.
ANd there's a surprise! He seems to have been married before. Which fits considering he was 34 when he married to the lady in our line, which seemed rather old to me.
Anyway, turns out he was married witha toddler and a newborn in the 1911 census. Unfortunately his first wife died a couple years later aged 25! She had a nerve disorder and was paraplegic for 18 months before her death. Seems so young, I wonder what caused it.
I also wonder what became of the kids. No sign of them upon second marriage and it seems they lived into old age.
Anyway, sad story but glad I finally got some info on him.
edit: found out the first marriage was also by sheriff substitute.