Hi Paddyscar
I have done as much as i can think of doing in the last two years to find ways of obtaining an original copy, even remembering that i had mailed the two web links above before (a lot of old emails miraculously dissapeared of my pc ) and had no response. I was told i could get this on interlibrary loan, my local one checked it out and i was told i would have to wait 6 months ish as there that was a copy out on loan.This was a while ago but will have to go and double check and joining might help !! How interlibrary loan works i dont know maybe for such a book the library keeps its and i have to view it there.
There are a lot of old book shops in Charing Cross Road in London so i am going to look there when i have a spare afternoon as its very close to work. My family in Scotland are also looking out.
Even just getting to see the book in The British Library i would be happy so i just need to arrange it.
I am going to hold of for a while longer in paying The British Library and National Library of Scotland,s hideous fee for copying the book as i think (wishful thinking that is) as soon as i do this someone will pop up with "found a copy"
He is also mentioned in another book...........recollections of Keith Fife- Keith and Newmill" p26-27 by John W Cowie - anecdotes about Donaldson which was published in 1928 so will start to chase that one as well now.
I dont know where the author got his information from i think he was more used to writing fiction than fact

k
Many many thanks, and any mail addresses welcomed as a reminder as said before i lost a lot (well, aol lost a lot

)
Scotland - Donaldson / Moggach / Shaw / Geddes / Sim / Gray / Mackie / Richards / Joel / Coull / Mckimmie / Panton / McGregor
Ireland and Scotland - Casey / McDade / Phillips / McCandle / Dinely / Comaskey + various spellings