Hi Maggie,
I think you've done very well in finding Agnes McNAUGHT's 1856 DC - and i believe she
is "yours".
Agnes died, as you know, in Elderslie - which was in the Abbey (Paisley) Parish.
This is well away from Bonhill, where you'd expect her to be...and died whilst visiting her son James & family...?
Agnes' DC may very well open up whole new lines of McNaughts (and other names) for you!
The censuses below (
in italics), i know you have.
--
I'm now very much suspecting - but no real proof as such,
that the JEAN McNAUGHTON (60) in 1841 Gallowgate is AGNES McNAUGHT,
and with her daur Jean GARDNER - maybe just a wee slip by hubby Thomas on his mo-in-law's name?
It's hard not to believe that the GARDNER children in 1841 aren't the same ones with gr-parents in 1851,
and so i'm sure you have the correct James (76) McNAUGHT & Agnes (74) in Bonhill 1851.
(James & son Arthur were in Burn Street 1841 - James & wife Agnes were in Burn Street 1851)
--
1841 cens 493 Ed 7 p 9 (Bonhill)
Burn Street
James McNAUGHT, 60, calico printer, j/man, b SCT
Arthur McNAUGHT, 20, calico printer, app, b DNB
--
1841 cens 644-1 Ed 68 p 20 (St. John)
Gallowgate, Glasgow.
// Thomas GARDNER, 30, engraver, b SCT
Jean GARDNER, 30, --------------------b SCT
Agness GARDNER, 4, ------------------b SCT
Jean GARDNER, 2, ----------------------b SCT
Margt. GARDNER, 4mos, ---------------b LKS
/ Jean McNAUGHTON, 60, --------------b SCT
Neil McNAUGHTON, 20, calico printer, ap, b SCT
Thomas DIXON, 20, calico printer, ap, b LKS
Agness NESBIT, 8yrs, --------------------b SCT
(a pity this Jean McNaughton aged 60 wasn't as Agnes....)
Is the above wee Agness NESBIT the daur of this couple below?
(Elizabeth being another of the daurs of James & Agnes)
JOHN NISBET
ELIZABETH MACNAUGHTON
Marriage: 05 SEP 1829 Bonhill, Dunbarton, Scotland
(they were possibly in the Greenock area 1841)
[they weren't - it's a different Nisbet family]
--
1851 cens 493 (394) Ed 8 p 13 (Bonhill)
Burn Street.
James McNAUGHT, head, marr, 76, pauper, formerly calico printer, b Luss, DNB
Agness McNAUGHT, wife, marr, 74, pauper, formerly calico printer, b Dumbarton, DNB
Jane GARDNER, gr-daur, 12yrs, printfield worker, b Glasgow, LKS
Margaret GARDNER, gr-daur, 10yrs, printfield worker, b Glasgow, LKS
James GARDNER, gr-son, 8yrs, scholar, b Glasgow, LKS
==
Is it brothers John & Thomas GARDNER married to sisters Margaret & Jean McNAUGHT(ON)...?
JOHN GARDNER
MARGARET MACNAUGHTAN
Marriage: 09 JUL 1826 Bonhill, Dunbarton, Scotland
1841 cens 493 Ed 6 pp 28-29 (Bonhill)
Gardiner's Land.
// James GARDINER, 70, print cutter, b DNB
// John GARDINER, 40, calico printer j/man, b DNB
Margt. GARDINER, 35, -------------------b DNB
Jane GARDINER, 11, tearer, ----------b DNB
James GARDINER, 9, -----------------b DNB
John GARDINER, 7, ------------------b DNB
Agnes GARDINER, 4, ---------------b DNB
Thomas GARDINER, 1, ---------b DNB
// James McNAUGHT, 25, calico printer j/man, b DNB
Agnes McNAUGHT, 25, ---------------------------b SCT
James McNAUGHT, 1, -------------------------b DNB
Above is the James McNAUGHT who i think was the informant son on Agnes' 1856 DC in Elderslie.
You'll notice in 1841 he's living beside a GARDINER family (just coincidence? maybe not),
and in 1851 he's in Elderslie - but as born Bonhill. Interestingly he has a son Arthur.
It might be well worth following him in the censuses, and also getting his DC
--
1851 cens 573-3 (470) Ed 5 p 28 (Abbey - Paisley)
48 Elderslie Village.
James McNAUGHT, head, marr, 36, block printer, b Bonhill, DNB
Agnes McNAUGHT, wife, marr, 37, -------------------b Buchlivie, STI
James McNAUGHT, son, 11, tearer at printwork, b Bonhill, DNB
Andrew McNAUGHT, son, 9, tearer at printwork, b Bonhill, DNB
Mary Ann McNAUGHT, daur, 7, scholar, b Bonhill, DNB
Alexander McNAUGHT, son, 5, scholar, b Bonhill, DNB
Arthur McNAUGHT, son, 3, ---------------b Elderslie, RFW
Agnes McNAUGHT, daur, 7mos, -------b Elderslie, RFW
==
And then there's this Neil, also worth a look at - is he the 20yr old in the Gallowgate in 1841?
[Thorn is very near to Elderslie - just to the west of]
1851 cens 573-3 (470) Ed 4 p 3 (Abbey - Paisley)
Thorn Village.
Neil McNAUGHT, head, marr, 29, calico printer, b b Bonhill, DNB
[Neil has shaved a few years off...maybe because wife is younger]
Janet McNAUGHT, wife, marr, 22, -----------------b Abbey, RFW
James McNAUGHT, son, 10mos, ----------------b Abbey, RFW
==
But it is a lot of guesswork...a fair bit of checking to prove, or disprove as the case may be....

Jack